A digital ID is trustworthy when verifiers can rely on it with confidence, holders can use it safely, and the broader ecosystem operates with integrity. Trust isn't a single feature, it's the result of multiple layers working together: strong issuance processes, tamper-proof technology, reliable verification methods, and robust governance.
The foundation: who issued it?
Trust begins at issuance. A credential is only as trustworthy as the authority that created it. When a DMV issues a mobile driver's license, banks and employers need assurance that the DMV followed rigorous processes to verify the person's identity before signing the credential.
This is why assurance levels matter. NIST's Digital Identity Guidelines (SP 800-63) define levels of identity assurance (IAL) that describe how thoroughly someone's identity was proofed before credential issuance. Higher assurance levels require more stringent checks, in-person verification, biometric matching, multiple documents, and provide greater confidence that the credential represents who it claims to represent.
Technical integrity: can it be trusted?
Beyond who issued it, verifiers need assurance that the credential hasn't been altered and is being presented by its rightful owner.
Digital signatures provide authenticity. When an issuer signs a credential with its private key, verifiers can check that signature against the issuer's public key. If the signature validates, the credential is authentic and unmodified. Any tampering invalidates the signature.
Device binding ensures the credential belongs to the presenter. The credential is cryptographically locked to a specific device through keys stored in secure hardware. Copying it to another device doesn't work, the required keys are missing.
Revocation status confirms the credential is still valid. Issuers must be able to suspend or revoke credentials that are compromised, expired, or no longer accurate. Verifiers check status lists to ensure they're not accepting credentials that should have been withdrawn.
The compliance question
For regulated industries like banking, trustworthiness has a specific meaning: will regulators accept this credential as satisfying compliance obligations?
Financial institutions must follow Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) rules. They need confidence that accepting a digital credential meets these requirements. Without explicit regulatory guidance affirming that verifiable digital credentials (VDCs) satisfy compliance, institutions hesitate to adopt them, regardless of how technically sound the credentials may be.
This regulatory clarity is emerging. The GENIUS Act, Treasury guidance, and NIST's work through the National Cybersecurity Center of Excellence are all helping define when and how VDCs can satisfy compliance requirements.
Certification and standards
Trustworthiness is reinforced through adherence to recognized standards and certification programs.
Open standards, such as ISO/IEC 18013-5 for mobile driver's licenses, W3C Verifiable Credentials, and NIST SP 800-63, provide consistent frameworks that issuers, wallets, and verifiers can rely on. When credentials conform to these standards, they become interoperable and predictable.
Certification programs, from FIDO for authentication, Kantara for governance, FIME for ISO conformance, provide independent verification that systems meet required security and privacy criteria. Certification marks give verifiers confidence that credentials come from audited, compliant environments.
Trust as a system property
Ultimately, trust in digital identity is a system property, not just a credential property. It requires trustworthy issuers operating under clear policies, secure technology that resists tampering and fraud, reliable verification methods available to all parties, governance frameworks that define roles and responsibilities, and regulatory acceptance that gives institutions confidence to act.
When all these elements align, VDCs become a trustworthy infrastructure that people and organizations can rely on.
Want to keep learning?
Subscribe to our blog.
